Ilkay Gundogan (De Bruyne 73') - 6. The German is easing his way towards match fitness after a disrupted pre-season. AP
LIVERPOOL RATINGS: Adrian - 5. The Spaniard made a good save from Haaland but his distribution was sloppy. He should have done much better before City’s equaliser. AP
Trent Alexander-Arnold - 7. The 23-year-old opened the scoring via a slight deflection by Ake. His distribution and crossing were marginally below his usual standard and he made way for Milner with 16 minutes to go. AFP
Joel Matip - 6. The 30-year-old had his hands full with Haaland but held his own. He seemed to switch off before City’s leveller. AFP
Virgil van Dijk - 7. The Dutchman was composed in the first half but was put under scrutiny in a physical battle with Haaland in the second period. AP
Andrew Robertson - 7. The Scot caused the City defence problems going forward and contributed to the third goal. He let Haaland get goalside but did just enough to disrupt the striker’s effort. PA
Jordan Henderson - 7. The captain ran himself into the ground and sent in dangerous crosses. Elliott replaced him in the 73rd minute but not before he created a chance for Nunez. Getty
Fabinho - 7. The Brazilian worked hard in the midfield and protected the defence. He made sure City did not dominate the centre of the pitch. Getty
Thiago Alcantara - 8. The 31-year-old fought hard for possession and made the most of it when he got the ball. His passing was incisive. He made way for Keita with five minutes to go. PA
Mohamed Salah - 9. The Egyptian was at his sharpest from the start. His pace terrified City and his goal from the penalty spot was a reward for a fine performance. Jones replaced him late in stoppage time. AFP
Roberto Firmino - 6. The Brazilian kept busy closing down opponents but rarely looked dangerous. He made way for Nunez in the 59th minute. Getty
Luis Diaz - 5. The Colombian never got into a rhythm. He found it hard to match effort with quality but he battled on until the final minute, when he was replaced by Carvalho. Getty
SUBS: Darwin Nunez (Firmino 59') - 8. The Uruguayan made an outstanding debut. His physical presence and pace gave the team a new threat. He was the catalyst for the penalty and scored with a header. A great start. AP
Harvey Elliott (Henderson 73') - 7. The 19-year-old's energy and appetite were impressive and he rarely gave away the ball. AP
James Milner (Alexander-Arnold 74') - 7. The 36-year-old was the essence of steadiness at the back and created an opportunity for Nunez. Reuters
Naby Keita (Thiago 85') - N/A. The Guinean saw out the final five minutes as a replacement for Thiago. He drove forward and looked to make the most of his cameo
Fabio Carvalho (Diaz 89') - N/A. The 19-year-old was given his debut when replacing Diaz in the final minute. He was involved in the build-up to Nunez’s goal and showed clear signs of promise. Getty
Curtis Jones (Salah 90'+5) - N/A. The 21-year-old replaced Salah deep in stoppage time but barely had a chance to get into the game. AFP
MANCHESTER CITY RATINGS: Ederson - 6. The Brazilian was quick off his line and made a good save from Nunez. He could do little about Liverpool’s goals. EPA
Kyle Walker - 7. The 32-year-old had some good moments up and down the line. He was rarely troubled by Diaz. AFP
Ruben Dias - 6. The Portuguese gave away the penalty by hanging his hand out but it was a rare lapse. He was otherwise solid and made a number of important interceptions. EPA
Nathan Ake - 6. The Dutchman had to attempt to play at Alexander-Arnold’s shot and was unfortunate to deflect it into the net. He used his strength to good effect at both ends of the pitch. Getty
Joao Cancelo - 4. The Portuguese gave Salah too much room. When he did get close to the striker, he was bewildered by the Egyptian’s pace and movement. He contributed little going forward. EPA
Kevin De Bruyne - 7. The Belgian went close to scoring in the first half and, while not at his sharpest, always presented a threat. He helped set up the equaliser before making way for Gundogan with 17 minutes left. Reuters
Rodri - 6. The Spaniard did his best to wrest control of the midfield but he needed more support. He was vulnerable to the counter-attack. PA
Bernardo Silva - 6. The Portuguese put in a lot of effort defensively but had less impact going forward. His passing lacked its normal precision. EPA
Riyad Mahrez - 5. The Algerian was nowhere near his best. He missed a chance to equalise and drifted offside too often. Alvarez replaced him in the 58th minute. PA
Erling Haaland - 7. The Norwegian missed a sitter at the end but showed enough to suggest that he is going to play a huge role in City’s season. His power, pace and movement deserved a better return. AP
Jack Grealish - 5. The 26-year-old was eager to get involved but could not make an impression on the game. He was substituted in the 58th minute for Foden. Reuters
SUBS: Julian Alvarez (Mahrez 58') - 7. The Argentinian replaced Mahrez and he scored on his debut. His arrival gave the team much more of a cutting edge. Reuters
Phil Foden (Grealish 58') - 7. The 22-year-old's direct running helped create the equaliser. City look more potent when he is in the team. AFP
Ilkay Gundogan (De Bruyne 73') - 6. The German is easing his way towards match fitness after a disrupted pre-season. AP
LIVERPOOL RATINGS: Adrian - 5. The Spaniard made a good save from Haaland but his distribution was sloppy. He should have done much better before City’s equaliser. AP
Trent Alexander-Arnold - 7. The 23-year-old opened the scoring via a slight deflection by Ake. His distribution and crossing were marginally below his usual standard and he made way for Milner with 16 minutes to go. AFP
Joel Matip - 6. The 30-year-old had his hands full with Haaland but held his own. He seemed to switch off before City’s leveller. AFP
Virgil van Dijk - 7. The Dutchman was composed in the first half but was put under scrutiny in a physical battle with Haaland in the second period. AP
Andrew Robertson - 7. The Scot caused the City defence problems going forward and contributed to the third goal. He let Haaland get goalside but did just enough to disrupt the striker’s effort. PA
Jordan Henderson - 7. The captain ran himself into the ground and sent in dangerous crosses. Elliott replaced him in the 73rd minute but not before he created a chance for Nunez. Getty
Fabinho - 7. The Brazilian worked hard in the midfield and protected the defence. He made sure City did not dominate the centre of the pitch. Getty
Thiago Alcantara - 8. The 31-year-old fought hard for possession and made the most of it when he got the ball. His passing was incisive. He made way for Keita with five minutes to go. PA
Mohamed Salah - 9. The Egyptian was at his sharpest from the start. His pace terrified City and his goal from the penalty spot was a reward for a fine performance. Jones replaced him late in stoppage time. AFP
Roberto Firmino - 6. The Brazilian kept busy closing down opponents but rarely looked dangerous. He made way for Nunez in the 59th minute. Getty
Luis Diaz - 5. The Colombian never got into a rhythm. He found it hard to match effort with quality but he battled on until the final minute, when he was replaced by Carvalho. Getty
SUBS: Darwin Nunez (Firmino 59') - 8. The Uruguayan made an outstanding debut. His physical presence and pace gave the team a new threat. He was the catalyst for the penalty and scored with a header. A great start. AP
Harvey Elliott (Henderson 73') - 7. The 19-year-old's energy and appetite were impressive and he rarely gave away the ball. AP
James Milner (Alexander-Arnold 74') - 7. The 36-year-old was the essence of steadiness at the back and created an opportunity for Nunez. Reuters
Naby Keita (Thiago 85') - N/A. The Guinean saw out the final five minutes as a replacement for Thiago. He drove forward and looked to make the most of his cameo
Fabio Carvalho (Diaz 89') - N/A. The 19-year-old was given his debut when replacing Diaz in the final minute. He was involved in the build-up to Nunez’s goal and showed clear signs of promise. Getty
Curtis Jones (Salah 90'+5) - N/A. The 21-year-old replaced Salah deep in stoppage time but barely had a chance to get into the game. AFP
MANCHESTER CITY RATINGS: Ederson - 6. The Brazilian was quick off his line and made a good save from Nunez. He could do little about Liverpool’s goals. EPA
Kyle Walker - 7. The 32-year-old had some good moments up and down the line. He was rarely troubled by Diaz. AFP
Ruben Dias - 6. The Portuguese gave away the penalty by hanging his hand out but it was a rare lapse. He was otherwise solid and made a number of important interceptions. EPA
Nathan Ake - 6. The Dutchman had to attempt to play at Alexander-Arnold’s shot and was unfortunate to deflect it into the net. He used his strength to good effect at both ends of the pitch. Getty
Joao Cancelo - 4. The Portuguese gave Salah too much room. When he did get close to the striker, he was bewildered by the Egyptian’s pace and movement. He contributed little going forward. EPA
Kevin De Bruyne - 7. The Belgian went close to scoring in the first half and, while not at his sharpest, always presented a threat. He helped set up the equaliser before making way for Gundogan with 17 minutes left. Reuters
Rodri - 6. The Spaniard did his best to wrest control of the midfield but he needed more support. He was vulnerable to the counter-attack. PA
Bernardo Silva - 6. The Portuguese put in a lot of effort defensively but had less impact going forward. His passing lacked its normal precision. EPA
Riyad Mahrez - 5. The Algerian was nowhere near his best. He missed a chance to equalise and drifted offside too often. Alvarez replaced him in the 58th minute. PA
Erling Haaland - 7. The Norwegian missed a sitter at the end but showed enough to suggest that he is going to play a huge role in City’s season. His power, pace and movement deserved a better return. AP
Jack Grealish - 5. The 26-year-old was eager to get involved but could not make an impression on the game. He was substituted in the 58th minute for Foden. Reuters
SUBS: Julian Alvarez (Mahrez 58') - 7. The Argentinian replaced Mahrez and he scored on his debut. His arrival gave the team much more of a cutting edge. Reuters
Phil Foden (Grealish 58') - 7. The 22-year-old's direct running helped create the equaliser. City look more potent when he is in the team. AFP
Ilkay Gundogan (De Bruyne 73') - 6. The German is easing his way towards match fitness after a disrupted pre-season. AP
