Elliot Anderson 6/10
(On for Willock, 62'): Did his best to make an impact. Krath (on for Botman, 83'): N/A. Getty Images
Stefan Ortega 7/10
CITY RATINGS. Crucial save from Isak in first half. Distribution typically bold albeit with a few hairy moments. EPA
Kyle Walker 6/10
Pace served him well defensively, otherwise a routine shift for England defender. Reuters
Ruben Dias 7/10
Solid game from centre-half who was back in the team after missing out against Liverpool. Reuters
Manuel Akanji 8/10
Impressive game from the Swiss who defended confidently and used the ball well. Getty Images
Josko Gvardiol 6/10
Assured display and joined in high up on the left when required. AFP
Rodri 7/10
Mature and controlled performance from the key midfielder. EPA
Mateo Kovacic 8/10
One of his better games for City. Sharp with the ball as he helped his side transition defence into attack. Reuters
Phil Foden 8/10
At the top of his game right now. Some sublime touches and runs as he looked to hurt Newcastle. PA
Bernardo Silva 8/10
Put his team in a commanding position with two deflected goals in the opening half. AP
Jeremy Doku 7/10
Another lively display from Belgian winger. Denied a deserved goal by decent saves from Dubravka. Getty Images
Erling Haaland 6/10
Some eye-catching bursts from deep but seemed laboured at times and not at his explosive best. AP
Oscar Bobb 6/10
CITY SUBS: Bobb (for Doku, 77'); Alvarez (for Haaland, 82'): N/A. Getty Images
Martin Dubravka 7/10
NEWCASTLE RATINGS. Beaten by two deflected shots but denied Doku with a couple of decent stops. EPA
Jamaal Lascelles 5/10
Determined effort but struggled at times and was booked for tug on Doku. Getty Images
Fabian Schar 6/10
Unfortunate to be booked for strong but fair challenge on Haaland. Reuters
Sven Botman 5/10
Not at his best and second goal deflected in off his head. AFP
Jacob Murphy 6/10
Worked hard down the right and put in a couple of dangerous crosses. Reuters
Dan Burn 5/10
Nodded down for Isak's chance but had a tough evening before being replaced in mass changes on the hour. AP
Bruno Guimaraes 6/10
Newcastle's best midfielder and kept trying to make things happen. Getty Images
Sean Longstaff 5/10
Largely anonymous in difficult night for the visitors. Replaced on the hour. Reuters
Joe Willock 4/10
Slow to close down Silva in prelude to opener. Another player hooked after an uninspiring display. Getty Images
Anthony Gordon 5/10
Didn't look fit after sustaining knock in previous game. Replaced on the hour. Getty Images
Alexander Isak 6/10
Missed Newcastle's best chance in first half and hesitated when well-placed after the break. EPA
Miguel Almiron 6/10
NEWCASTLE SUBS: Almiron (on for Gordon, 62') - Injected some energy into Newcastle attack. PA
Lewis Miley 6/10
(On for Longstaff, 62'): Some nice touches in closing stages. EPA
Lewis Hall 6/10
(On for Burn, 62'): Brought some purpose down the left. EPAElliot Anderson 6/10
(On for Willock, 62'): Did his best to make an impact. Krath (on for Botman, 83'): N/A. Getty ImagesStefan Ortega 7/10
CITY RATINGS. Crucial save from Isak in first half. Distribution typically bold albeit with a few hairy moments. EPAKyle Walker 6/10
Pace served him well defensively, otherwise a routine shift for England defender. ReutersRuben Dias 7/10
Solid game from centre-half who was back in the team after missing out against Liverpool. ReutersManuel Akanji 8/10
Impressive game from the Swiss who defended confidently and used the ball well. Getty ImagesJosko Gvardiol 6/10
Assured display and joined in high up on the left when required. AFPRodri 7/10
Mature and controlled performance from the key midfielder. EPAMateo Kovacic 8/10
One of his better games for City. Sharp with the ball as he helped his side transition defence into attack. ReutersPhil Foden 8/10
At the top of his game right now. Some sublime touches and runs as he looked to hurt Newcastle. PABernardo Silva 8/10
Put his team in a commanding position with two deflected goals in the opening half. APJeremy Doku 7/10
Another lively display from Belgian winger. Denied a deserved goal by decent saves from Dubravka. Getty ImagesErling Haaland 6/10
Some eye-catching bursts from deep but seemed laboured at times and not at his explosive best. APOscar Bobb 6/10
CITY SUBS: Bobb (for Doku, 77'); Alvarez (for Haaland, 82'): N/A. Getty ImagesMartin Dubravka 7/10
NEWCASTLE RATINGS. Beaten by two deflected shots but denied Doku with a couple of decent stops. EPAJamaal Lascelles 5/10
Determined effort but struggled at times and was booked for tug on Doku. Getty ImagesFabian Schar 6/10
Unfortunate to be booked for strong but fair challenge on Haaland. ReutersSven Botman 5/10
Not at his best and second goal deflected in off his head. AFPJacob Murphy 6/10
Worked hard down the right and put in a couple of dangerous crosses. ReutersDan Burn 5/10
Nodded down for Isak's chance but had a tough evening before being replaced in mass changes on the hour. APBruno Guimaraes 6/10
Newcastle's best midfielder and kept trying to make things happen. Getty ImagesSean Longstaff 5/10
Largely anonymous in difficult night for the visitors. Replaced on the hour. ReutersJoe Willock 4/10
Slow to close down Silva in prelude to opener. Another player hooked after an uninspiring display. Getty ImagesAnthony Gordon 5/10
Didn't look fit after sustaining knock in previous game. Replaced on the hour. Getty ImagesAlexander Isak 6/10
Missed Newcastle's best chance in first half and hesitated when well-placed after the break. EPAMiguel Almiron 6/10
NEWCASTLE SUBS: Almiron (on for Gordon, 62') - Injected some energy into Newcastle attack. PALewis Miley 6/10
(On for Longstaff, 62'): Some nice touches in closing stages. EPALewis Hall 6/10
(On for Burn, 62'): Brought some purpose down the left. EPAElliot Anderson 6/10
(On for Willock, 62'): Did his best to make an impact. Krath (on for Botman, 83'): N/A. Getty ImagesMan City v Newcastle player ratings: Silva 8, Haaland 6; Isak 6, Willock 4
FA Cup holders advance to semi-finals for sixth straight season with 2-0 win at Etihad Stadium
Andy Lewis
March 17, 2024
- Listen In English
- Listen In Arabic