New research from Citywire has found that despite their big salaries, two out of three fund managers failed to meet their benchmarks last year. Ki Price / AFP
New research from Citywire has found that despite their big salaries, two out of three fund managers failed to meet their benchmarks last year. Ki Price / AFP

Exchange-traded funds run rings around many fund managers



Here's a bold proposal: two out of three fund managers should be fired. They should lose their jobs, forthwith. And who should replace them? That's easy. Computers.

Why so harsh? Because an astonishing two out of three fund managers failed to beat their benchmark last year. The research, from Citywire, a London-based financial services publisher, shows that only one in three managers added value in 2011. The rest failed to justify their hefty charges.

The research covered 1,800 active funds across a range of asset classes, including equities, bonds, property and commodities. Year after year, just one in three fund managers justify their existence by beating their benchmark index. Last year was a particularly bad year, but it wasn't that unusual.

This research appears to boost the arguments in favour of investing in low-cost "passive" index-tracking mutual funds and hugely popular exchange-traded funds (ETFs). Instead of paying a fund manager a handsome salary to outperform the index, they passively track the performance of a chosen index.

Citywire's research suggests that two times out of three, they will come out on top. You will also save a small fortune in fees.

Now two out of three ain't bad, so should you ditch your overpriced, actively managed mutual funds and embrace cut-price trackers instead? Or is the decision more complicated than it seems?

The passive versus active debate has been raging for years and will never be fully resolved either way. But lately, the balance has swung in favour of trackers thanks to the explosive popularity of ETFs: passive, low-cost investment funds that are traded like shares.

State Street Global Advisers launched the first ETF in 1993, tracking the S&P 500. Trustnetoffshore.com now lists nearly 2,500 ETFs from 63 investment groups, including Barclays Capital, BlackRock, DB Platinum Advisers, ETF Securities, Invesco PowerShare, iShares and US ProShares. Gold ETFs have been particularly popular lately. If you want to track, you won't be short of choice.

ETFs offer a number of advantages over traditional mutual funds, says David Gardner, the head of sales for iShares EMEA, which offers 460 global ETFs traded on 19 exchanges worldwide.

"ETFs give investors access to markets and asset classes in a precise and cost-efficient way, so you know exactly which markets, stocks, bonds or commodities you are invested in at any time," Mr Gardner says. "They also offer intra-day pricing, which means you can see the value of your holdings continuously and take investment decisions based on this information."

By contrast, many mutual funds are priced just once a day. If you sell or buy during a spell of volatility, you can't be certain what price the deal will be executed at. "ETFs can help you take advantage of tactical opportunities because you can buy them quickly, cheaply and efficiently."

Mr Gardner says its investors use ETFs as a building block to establish their core portfolio holdings. "They often combine ETFs with a selection of active funds, which have consistently outperformed their index."

For most investors, a portfolio of passive ETFs is the best option, says Peter Barr, a senior investment analyst at the Dubai-based Holborn Group, a financial services company.

"The cost savings alone are likely to result in significant outperformance against a portfolio of actively managed funds," Mr Barr says.

Many investors don't realise how much of a drag fund charges can inflict on performance. Say you invest a lump sum of US$10,000 (Dh36,732) in an active fund with a typical initial charge of 5 per cent and an annual management fee of 1.5 per cent.

That initial charge immediately swallows $500 of your money. So you only actually invest $9,500. But it's the smaller 1.5 per cent annual management fee that does most of the damage because you pay it year after year.

If the fund grows at 6 per cent a year, your fund will be worth $14,753 after 10 years, after charges. That doesn't sound bad, until you compare it with ETFs.

The average ETF has no initial charge and an annual fee of about 0.5 per cent. If you invested $10,000 and it grew at the same 6 per cent a year, you would have $17,081 after 10 years. That's an extra $2,328.

The difference becomes more marked over time. Over 20 years, you would have $22,911 in the mutual fund, assuming 6 per cent growth, but $29,178 in the ETF. That's $6,267 more.

Charges aren't everything, Mr Barr says. "Some actively managed funds perform very well. The trouble is that identifying those funds ahead of time is extremely difficult. Historical data tells us that past performance doesn't correlate with future performance. Simply picking the best-performing funds from previous years is unlikely to be a good strategy," he says.

This doesn't mean you should always prefer an ETF. Your decision partly depends on the sector or market you are investing in. "Fund managers investing in global bonds have the worst record of beating their benchmarks," Mr Barr says. "Funds investing in developed western markets also struggle. If you are choosing between an ETF tracking the UK FTSE 100 and an actively managed fund investing in large cap UK stocks, the ETF has the edge."

Yet active managers specialising in smaller companies, emerging markets and Japan have a much better record of beating their benchmarks. "You should lean towards actively managed funds in these sectors," Mr Barr says.

Trackers and ETFs aren't exactly perfect either.

The first problem is that you will never, ever beat the market. In fact, if you take out a tracker, you are buying guaranteed underperformance, says Rob Worthington, an academy sales manager at JP Morgan Asset Management, the fund manager. "Trackers charge an annual fee of between 0.3 per cent and 1.55 per cent a year and this comes from your returns. You will always get less than the index, after charges have been deducted. Whereas the best managers can beat the market, trackers will always underperform."

Another problem is that some ETFs don't actually invest in the physical products they are tracking. Instead of actually buying the components of an index, so-called "synthetic" ETFs give your cash to an investment bank, a "counterparty", which promises to match the return on that index.

The banks usually do this by using complex derivative swap contracts. "Investment banks are under a lot of pressure at the moment. If something happens to the counterparty bank, your money is at risk. This is a risk you simply can't measure and probably don't want to take," Mr Worthington says.

Many synthetic ETFs also have a tracking error, which tends to get worse over time and may eventually lead to serious underperformance. So if you are buying an ETF, you need to make your choice very carefully.

Mr Worthington points out that trackers only follow the fortunes of companies once they have entered the index. "An ETF will never catch the next Apple at an early stage, it will only invest in it once it has grown large enough to hit the index."

Index tracking can be particularly dangerous in emerging markets such as China, where corporate governance is still a problem. "If you buy a tracker, you are buying good and bad companies. If you invest with a fund manager, they have to carry out due diligence on any stocks they invest in. You pay higher charges for that, but we believe that is a price worth paying. One of our managers recently visited China to see a large paper milling company. It looked a great prospect, until he checked out one of the company's forests. It was a car park. A passive fund would have invested in that car park," Mr Worthington says.

The big problem with fund managers is that some underperform year after year, often for a decade or more, says Mark Dampier, the head of research at Hargreaves Lansdown, the UK's largest independent financial advisers. "There aren't that many talented fund managers. That's what drags down the overall performance figures for actively managed funds. Yet people leave billions of dollars sitting in these funds getting a lousy return. Why they stick with these funds beats me, but they do, and that makes fund managers look bad generally."

You need to seek out managers with a proven track record of outperformance, year after year. "Even a good fund manager won't beat the index every year, but over five or 10 years, they should come out comfortably on top. Look for a fund investing in a sector or theme that you understand, with clear aims and strong management. That should give you a good chance of picking a winner," Mr Dampier says.

The daft thing about mutual funds is that the bad ones charge exactly the same as the good ones. "With most products, you pay more for quality. That's not the case with funds. This is something the industry should address."

Consumers should shoulder some of the blame, Mr Dampier says. "They are too willing to put up with bad performance and high fees. They should vote with their feet and move on."

Two out of three fund managers won't be fired and replaced with a computer. Instead, most will be rewarded with fat bonuses. But you can fire the underperformers - from your portfolio.

Hang onto the winners, though.

Nine EFTs

Gold

SPDR Gold Shares Trust (GLD)

US large cap stocks

SPDR S&P 500 (SPY)

Emerging market stocks

iShares MSCI Emerging Index Fund (EEM)

Commodities

iShares S&P GSCI Commodity ETF (GSG)

European stocks

iShares S&P Europe 350 (IEV)

US bonds

Vanguard Total Bond Market ETF (BND)

Japan stocks

iShares MSCI Japan ETF (EWJ)

Asia stocks

iShares MSCI Pacific ex-Japan (EPP)

UK stocks

iShares FTSE 100 (ISF.L)

Source: Peter Barr, Holborn Group

COMPANY PROFILE
Name: Kumulus Water
 
Started: 2021
 
Founders: Iheb Triki and Mohamed Ali Abid
 
Based: Tunisia 
 
Sector: Water technology 
 
Number of staff: 22 
 
Investment raised: $4 million 
Army of the Dead

Director: Zack Snyder

Stars: Dave Bautista, Ella Purnell, Omari Hardwick, Ana de la Reguera

Three stars

Dr Afridi's warning signs of digital addiction

Spending an excessive amount of time on the phone.

Neglecting personal, social, or academic responsibilities.

Losing interest in other activities or hobbies that were once enjoyed.

Having withdrawal symptoms like feeling anxious, restless, or upset when the technology is not available.

Experiencing sleep disturbances or changes in sleep patterns.

What are the guidelines?

Under 18 months: Avoid screen time altogether, except for video chatting with family.

Aged 18-24 months: If screens are introduced, it should be high-quality content watched with a caregiver to help the child understand what they are seeing.

Aged 2-5 years: Limit to one-hour per day of high-quality programming, with co-viewing whenever possible.

Aged 6-12 years: Set consistent limits on screen time to ensure it does not interfere with sleep, physical activity, or social interactions.

Teenagers: Encourage a balanced approach – screens should not replace sleep, exercise, or face-to-face socialisation.

Source: American Paediatric Association
The specs

Engine: 4.0-litre V8

Power: 503hp at 6,000rpm

Torque: 685Nm at 2,000rpm

Transmission: 8-speed auto

Price: from Dh850,000

On sale: now

Specs
Engine: Electric motor generating 54.2kWh (Cooper SE and Aceman SE), 64.6kW (Countryman All4 SE)
Power: 218hp (Cooper and Aceman), 313hp (Countryman)
Torque: 330Nm (Cooper and Aceman), 494Nm (Countryman)
On sale: Now
Price: From Dh158,000 (Cooper), Dh168,000 (Aceman), Dh132,000 (Countryman)
MATCH INFO

What: 2006 World Cup quarter-final
When: July 1
Where: Gelsenkirchen Stadium, Gelsenkirchen, Germany

Result:
England 0 Portugal 0
(Portugal win 3-1 on penalties)

If you go...

Fly from Dubai or Abu Dhabi to Chiang Mai in Thailand, via Bangkok, before taking a five-hour bus ride across the Laos border to Huay Xai. The land border crossing at Huay Xai is a well-trodden route, meaning entry is swift, though travellers should be aware of visa requirements for both countries.

Flights from Dubai start at Dh4,000 return with Emirates, while Etihad flights from Abu Dhabi start at Dh2,000. Local buses can be booked in Chiang Mai from around Dh50

The specs

Engine: Direct injection 4-cylinder 1.4-litre
Power: 150hp
Torque: 250Nm
Price: From Dh139,000
On sale: Now

Meatless Days
Sara Suleri, with an introduction by Kamila Shamsie
​​​​​​​Penguin 

The specs: 2018 Volkswagen Teramont

Price, base / as tested Dh137,000 / Dh189,950

Engine 3.6-litre V6

Gearbox Eight-speed automatic

Power 280hp @ 6,200rpm

Torque 360Nm @ 2,750rpm

Fuel economy, combined 11.7L / 100km

A State of Passion

Directors: Carol Mansour and Muna Khalidi

Stars: Dr Ghassan Abu-Sittah

Rating: 4/5

The%20specs
%3Cp%3E%3Cstrong%3EEngine%3A%20%3C%2Fstrong%3E4.0-litre%20twin-turbo%20V8%0D%3Cbr%3E%3Cstrong%3EPower%3A%20%3C%2Fstrong%3E640hp%20at%206%2C000rpm%0D%3Cbr%3E%3Cstrong%3ETorque%3A%20%3C%2Fstrong%3E850Nm%20from%202%2C300-4%2C500rpm%0D%3Cbr%3E%3Cstrong%3ETransmission%3A%20%3C%2Fstrong%3E8-speed%20auto%0D%3Cbr%3E%3Cstrong%3EFuel%20consumption%3A%20%3C%2Fstrong%3E11.9L%2F100km%0D%3Cbr%3E%3Cstrong%3EPrice%3A%20%3C%2Fstrong%3EDh749%2C800%0D%3Cbr%3E%3Cstrong%3EOn%20sale%3A%20%3C%2Fstrong%3Enow%3C%2Fp%3E%0A
The specs

Engine: Four electric motors, one at each wheel

Power: 579hp

Torque: 859Nm

Transmission: Single-speed automatic

Price: From Dh825,900

On sale: Now

A cheaper choice

Vanuatu: $130,000

Why on earth pick Vanuatu? Easy. The South Pacific country has no income tax, wealth tax, capital gains or inheritance tax. And in 2015, when it was hit by Cyclone Pam, it signed an agreement with the EU that gave it some serious passport power.

Cost: A minimum investment of $130,000 for a family of up to four, plus $25,000 in fees.

Criteria: Applicants must have a minimum net worth of $250,000. The process take six to eight weeks, after which the investor must travel to Vanuatu or Hong Kong to take the oath of allegiance. Citizenship and passport are normally provided on the same day.

Benefits:  No tax, no restrictions on dual citizenship, no requirement to visit or reside to retain a passport. Visa-free access to 129 countries.

The specs
Engine: 77.4kW all-wheel-drive dual motor
Power: 320bhp
Torque: 605Nm
Transmission: Single-speed automatic
Price: From Dh219,000
On sale: Now
The bio

Favourite book: Peter Rabbit. I used to read it to my three children and still read it myself. If I am feeling down it brings back good memories.

Best thing about your job: Getting to help people. My mum always told me never to pass up an opportunity to do a good deed.

Best part of life in the UAE: The weather. The constant sunshine is amazing and there is always something to do, you have so many options when it comes to how to spend your day.

Favourite holiday destination: Malaysia. I went there for my honeymoon and ended up volunteering to teach local children for a few hours each day. It is such a special place and I plan to retire there one day.

The specs

Engine: Dual 180kW and 300kW front and rear motors

Power: 480kW

Torque: 850Nm

Transmission: Single-speed automatic

Price: From Dh359,900 ($98,000)

On sale: Now

DUBAI%20BLING%3A%20EPISODE%201
%3Cp%3E%3Cstrong%3ECreator%3A%20%3C%2Fstrong%3ENetflix%3C%2Fp%3E%0A%3Cp%3E%3Cstrong%3EStars%3A%20%3C%2Fstrong%3EKris%20Fade%2C%20Ebraheem%20Al%20Samadi%2C%20Zeina%20Khoury%3C%2Fp%3E%0A%3Cp%3E%3Cstrong%3ERating%3A%3C%2Fstrong%3E%202%2F5%3C%2Fp%3E%0A